9.07.2006

oh, stuff

Firstly, it's clear that nothing claiming to be news can get away without mentioning Facebook right now. It's in the NY Times, Time, WSJ, and of course innumerable college rags... Yep. People are making such a huge stink out of a new feature that pretty much just shoves in your face what we'd rather ignore - how much you make yourself trackable by putting all your ever-so-trivial details and plans and stuff out there into the 'social network'.
The paradox is revealed: if you are only friends on facebook with your real friends who already know everything about you, then it doesn't matter that they can see who else you're friends with and what you're writing about and what your cat ate for breakfast - it doesn't matter that this is in your face, because you either know it already or (theoretically) find some value in this data inasmuch as it might complement your interpersonal relationship somehow... well, that's what they're claiming. I totally agree - you're putting all this info out there anyway, so why get your knickers in a twist over it being seen all in one place?
Well, because people just don't use facebook as a complementary social tool very well. They use it as an exclusive social tool, one that encompasses a whole e-cyber-inter-webber-personality which you can create yourself, a fictionalized avatar of yourself whose departures from reality can run the gamut from wee little white lies to thoroughly deceptive claims that run counter to everything that reality, that harsh mistress, asserts. So, yeah, if you're busy being cooler on facebook than you think you are in real life, it can be shocking and even frightening to see what it all boils down to: so-and-so broke up with so-and-so (ooohh!) and A joined group B and C is friends with D and E wrote something to F about the party that they're going to with G and on and on and on... all-too-conveniently packaged in a list that now occupies most of your screen. It's frightening, yet for all it purports to tell us about our acquaintences, it doesn't say anything new (or even anything that interesting).
Of course, what you don't often hear - amongst all this badmouthing of "StalkerBook" and all the hype about how many people have joined groups (on facebook) protesting the creepiness of facebook (yes, on facebook) - is that this new packaging is easily defeatable. You can hide your actions with just one more click than before - because yes, all this information was there before, but someone had to be really trying hard to keep up with it. Now you can hide it when you do something silly or embarassing or just somewhat uncool, and you can reclaim that real estate on your screen with another click. The feed window collapses in on itself quite neatly, and it just waits patiently for you to reopen it. Because, after all, there's an undeniable appeal in this quasi-omniscient perspective, a whisper to the voyeur in all of us that hey, now it's ok! Go ahead, don't bother leaving your screen, feel like you've been interacting with your friends without even getting up. Hey, that's not all there is, I know. But that's part of it.
I don't know how much trouble this is actually causing facebook. A few people I know have left the site, deleting their profiles and erasing all traces of their weaving in this weird web... and you know what? My facebook feed doesn't tell me this. I have no concise memo displayed when I log in about who is no longer there. I have to actually hunt people down or hear through good old word-of-mouth when that happens... so maybe this isn't such a bad thing after all, because that's really what it's all about: finding people to really interact with. Will the .com be that empty if only 8 million people are involved instead of the 9+ million currently subscribed? And are there that many people who had fooled themselves in the first place into thinking that they had so much privacy in that world that this new perspective is actually hurting them?
A caveat, naturally - I can't help but smirk a little (a lot) at the delicious irony which is filling the whole network during this time of absurd protest. Yes, it's facebook that everyone is using to protest facebook, yes, I cross-post this blog to my 'notes' on facebook and it will join a million rants and whines about the same exact thing. But that's the whole point, really - no matter how much we find ourselves frustrated and freaked-out about the frightening detail with which we make ourselves available online, we can't help but love it at the same time. So what if everyone can see what you're doing more easily than before? Why not get crazy and join the groups you've always wanted to? Say you're writing a great novel, say you're masturbating, whatever. Remember, it's just an avatar. It's not YOU. And everyone's watching you perform.

1 comment:

Anonymous said...

Eloquent as always, so instead of adding my two cents about all that d@*#ed ridiculousness, I'll just commend you :)

e